STATE OF PAKISTAN

Folks,

This truly is a hard hitting editoril......but is any one listening in Pakistan !!

    This editorial, by a well known Pak columnist in a prestigious Pak newspaper, should be read carefully by everyone both in Pakistan and in India !!

    (1) It demolishes yet again the carefully cultivated myth in Pakistan that Pakistan won the 1965 Indo-Pak war, and it is still being celebrated as "victory day" in Pakistan !!  But there are some in India too who believe that this is true.

    (2) Najam Sethi gives us a true perspective of Pak relations with the countries that matter, like China, Saudi Arabia and of course the USA.

ENJOY

Injo

TFT CURRENT ISSUE| October 07-13, 2011 - Vol. XXIII, No. 34Editorial By Najam Sethi

Wake up Pakistan !!!

            US-Pak relations have broken down. The United States has "suspended" military aid and all but closed the Kerry-Lugar-Berman tap of funds for the civilians.

             US-Pak relations have broken down.  The United States has "suspended" military aid and all but closed the Kerry-Lugar-Berman tap of funds for the civilians.  Proud Pakistanis have puffed up their chests and vowed to eat grass, if necessary, in order to defend the "sovereignty" of their country.  What's the big deal, they aver, US aid was peanuts anyway, and our traditional friends like China and Saudi Arabia are at hand to bail us out of our problems.

        To be sure, our relationship with the US has been no small disaster.

        In the 1950s, we begged the US to befriend us instead of India, cheerily going along with the US into the cold war against the USSR when it wasn't our war at all. In consequence, the military became the dominant theme of our life and wrecked the budding impulse of democracy.  Once again, in the 1980s and 2000s, we tripped over ourselves to rent out our services to the US in Afghanistan.  Today, we are reaping the terrorist whirlwind of our greed and opportunism.

            But a little introspection is in order to prove that we don't need the US as an enemy because we are our own worst enemies.

              More Pakistanis are eating "grass" now than ever before.  The number of Pakistanis below the poverty line has increased from 27 per cent five years ago to 33 per cent in 2011.  And, this has nothing to do with the US.

           The growth rate of the economy has fallen from 6.5% five years ago to 3% now. The fiscal deficit is yawning at 7.5% of GDP today compared to 4.5% five years ago. And this has nothing to do with the US.

          The Rupee has fallen from 77 to the dollar five years ago to 90 today.  General inflation is running at 15% and food inflation at 25%.  And this has nothing to do with the US.   

            The tax to GDP ratio is down to 8.7% in 2011 from 11.5% five years ago.  And this has nothing to do with the US.

          Floods continue to devastate the lives and produce of millions of poor people across the country.  And this has nothing to do with the US.

         Sunni extremists are rampaging, killing Shias. Ethnic parties continue to mow down people in Karachi.  And this has nothing to do with the US.

          Power breakdowns have made the lives of tens of millions wretched and miserable while rendering millions of others jobless.  And this has nothing to do with the US.

         Instead of rooting for Pakistani nationalism, we are proud to undermine it as Muslims first, or Sindhis, Muhajirs, Baloch, Pakhtun, Punjabi, Seraiki, Hazarajat, Kashmiri, Sunni, Shia, Deobandi, Barelvi.  And this has nothing to do with the US.

          We are counted amongst the most corrupt countries of the world.  We have waged four wars with India and lost each of them and in the bargain losing half of Pakistan. And this has nothing to do with the US.

         As if this litany of self-induced failures isn't enough, there is the hypocrisy of double standards to contend with too.

         Of course, the US has violated our sovereignty by raining drones on FATA.  But so have the Afghan Taliban and Al-Qaeda who have established safe havens there too.  But we are quick to blast the US and quicker still to pretend that Al-Qaeda doesn't exist and the Taliban are innocent refugees for whom our traditional hospitality is on offer.

        The story doesn't end here.

         The IMF is not welcome.  How dare it demand that we tax the rich, plug the bleeding in public sector corporations, stop the theft of power, and spend according to our means.

         US aid is dispensable.  We don't need to build dams and reservoirs for managing our natural resources, we don't need schools and teachers for our children and hospitals for the poor.

         Our all-weather friends are China and Saudi Arabia.  Never mind that China doesn't help us much when we are ravaged by earthquakes and floods or when we are short of cash to pay our foreign bills.  Never mind that Saudi Arabia treats our migrant workers like slaves, rents our military to crack down on Shia majorities in Bahrain and exports extremist "Islam" to our lands.

         At the end of the day, who eats grass when we rise to defend our sovereignty ?  Not our pot bellied traders and businessmen.  Not our golf-playing generals.  Not our Defence Housing Society residents.  Not our foreign-asset holding politicians whose kids go to English-medium private schools at home and abroad.  Not our self-righteous media Mughals who berate our slavish black-skins and white masks.  Not our corrupt judges and civil servants.  It's the wretched of the earth, the poorest of the poor, who eat grass.

         For too long we have made foreign scapegoats for our own failures and corruptions.  It is time to wake up and set our house in order without begging or berating the US.

           Can you disagree with Najam Sethi ???