Total Pageviews

Saturday, 10 November 2012

how the 1962 War tore a family

This is not a new story. This story is not one looking for sympathy or pity, as all of these days have been left far far behind. This is not a common story of the loss and desperation of a family but rather it is the story of a very brave woman's struggle with life and its vagaries, in face of a terrible calamity.
A very long long time ago, there lived two little princesses in a small mofussil town called Mhow. In those faraway days it was quiet, much quieter than now with small well-maintained houses, few cars that only the privileged owned. Life was absolutely idyllic. Nothing seemed amiss in the lives of these princesses who went to school, came back to adoring parents, played badminton and cycled in the evenings, had Vimto in the DSOI and then shared stories and hearty laughs on their dining table with their father and mother. Sundays were meant for family picnics and vacations meant long road trips to Saurashtra or to the family home in UP. The princesses had everything.
But someone, somewhere had other plans. "There are no fairy tales," he must have told himself when he saw this family's complete happiness. So, then came the 1962 War. The man of the house, the beloved father, the mainstay of the family, left a shell-shocked and young wife and two little lost girls within a matter of 48 hours. The days of hope and faith were shattered by bad news one day and the little ones were left fatherless in less than one month.
Overnight the queen turned into an outcast and her little princesses into little Cindrellas, except that they had no roof over their heads and no shoes to look forward to.
The wretched and real day found her and her two girls sitting on black boxes, painted with Mhow to ---- written on them, on the roadside. Rain was pelting down and the queen did not know where to take her luggage and her girls. The rain hid her tears from her girls as they mixed with each other on her soaked cheeks. A very kind-hearted and generous family, passing by, just took them home, piled her luggage in the verandah and looked after their broken souls and bodies, for a few weeks.
Back in those days, educated women were few and far between. Not many had attended a university and even lesser number had the distinction of having been tutored by luminaries like Harivansh Rai Bachchan. The queen looked for a place to hide herself and her little girls while she found a job to support them. But no help was forthcoming from any quarter. She enrolled herself for a post-graduate degree so that she could get a teaching job. Months passed on and not being able to tolerate the pain that her girls underwent and the regular barbs and taunts from the relatives where they had found temporary but very reluctant shelter, the queen placed her girls in a hostel, in another town.
Every weekend she would travel to see her beloved daughters: take one train that arrived at her destination at 1 pm. She would rush to the school and feed her girls some homemade 'aloo puri' and rush back to the station to take her 3 pm train back to the place she called home for a few months. Since she could not afford a coolie, or a rickshaw or new flat-soled sandals, she trudged on her old high heels, painful remnants of her past life, to the school. Her feet were torn and hurt. They ached and pained from having had to walk miles...actually not walked but run... as she had a train to take back. Her back hurt from having to toil over books. She burned the midnight oil quite literally to get her MA degree. By the end of it, she had spectacles.
But adversity brought out the best in her. Over the years, she carved out a place for herself. Her daughters studied in a very well-known, expensive boarding school.
She braved it. She became strong. After all she was a queen, the wife of an Army officer, who had laid down his life for the country. She got a job of a lecturer in a government college and in her paltry salary of few hundreds, proceeded to bring up her girls single-handedly. The girls went from strength to strength. They did well at studies and were aware of the sacrifices that their mother was making for them. They participated in extra-curricular activities and shone in them all. The older one was better at music. She won several awards which made her mother proud.
Then, like all growing girls, the older princess found her prince charming... Alas, he too was in the Army. The Mother did not bat an eyelid and did not once say that she had her reservations because another loss of a loved one was too much to think of. But she killed her fears and married her girl off with great pomp amd splendour. There were elephants and horses to welcome the baraat and the town talked of the wedding for months.
The younger princess qualified to be a doctor and the brave mother ran from pillar to post to secure a good scholarship as financially it was a daunting task. But she managed it somehow. Today that little one is a very successful doctor in the US.
The older girl grew up to be an Army wife....once again thrown into the same life style as her father's time. The happy couple moved from place to place, following the drum. And like all growing young people, they had two lovely children who needed grandmotherly attention every now and then. Once the couple had to go abroad as the young officer had qualified for a Staff College assignment. The queen volunteered to take care of the very young children single-handedly so that her daughter could accompany the husband abroad. She stayed awake through the nights, tutored the young kids, went to work everyday and toiled endlessly, selflessly.
At every step, her support became invaluable. She brought up her grandson as it was not possible to send a young boy to small places where no schooling was possible. The princess travelled up the ladder as her husband did well in life. From a little lost girl, with two frocks and torn shoes, she became part of the senior lot in the hierarchy.
From a small rented room where she slept on the floor, the princess moved to large mansions with several bedrooms and several people to take care of her comforts. Her mother began to live with her and provide a home to her. Life was just too busy to ever be at home and to look after it properly. At every step, it was the mother who stood by her daughter. Her graciousness and elegance became legendary in the regiment as also in the Army elsewhere. She was spoken of as NANI...to all. A woman loved, for her substance. She became an author and a poetess, having published two books and several magazines and TV channels covered her brave journey. She moved with the Page 3 circuit.
When she passed away, her bier bore a wreath from the Chief of Army Staff himself. Her life was celebrated and feted by a host of well-known people. For us, it was a proud moment.
It was a long road from penury and widowhood. But she made it with tenacity, grace and a large heartedness. The soldier would have been proud of her.
I should know. I am her daughter: the elder of the princesses.
I am Neeharika Naidu, wife of Lt Gen. Milan Naidu, PVSM, AVSM, YSM,ADC, former Vice-Chief of Army Staff.
She was Sushila Avasthy, the queen, wife of Lt Col Brahmanand Avasthy, Commanding Officer, 4 Rajput, killed in action in 1962.
This brings us to a question. Should people who have lost their reason to survive be made to grovel and beg for their rightful place under the sun? Should not have those, for whom my father gave his life, stood with us and helped us to live a life of dignity, respect and comfort just like they were? Was it his fault or ours that today those years of 1962 onwards are a memory that I dare not invoke without inviting a sense of deep pain and ignominy? Can someone answer me? Anyone?
The powers that be, the people that are, or those who were. Can anybody give me back some vestige of what we lost? Why is it that his bravery and that of those who fought and fell with him were not recognised as of those in the more recent wars? No roads are named after them, no songs in their praise and certainly no government organisation, school and colleges hold rememberance ceremonies. No petrol pumps and special bounties were handed down to their families. Why? Were they nobodies, just cannon fodder?
Now, tell me honestly, can anyone imagine a better tale?

पाकिस्तानशी हिंदुस्थानने क्रिकेट खेळावे काय

पाकड्या अतिरेकी कसाबला एक मच्छर चावला आणि त्यास ‘डेंग्यू’ नावाचा आजार जडला. त्या मच्छराच्या मर्दपणाचे कौतुक करावे तेवढे थोडेच.
मच्छरांचे शौर्य
पाकिस्तानशी हिंदुस्थानने क्रिकेट खेळावे काय? हिंदुस्थानची कडवट देशाभिमानी जनता ओरडून सांगत आहे, ‘नाही! पाकिस्तानशी क्रिकेट आम्हाला कदापि मंजूर नाही!’ पण देशाचे दुर्दैव असे की, त्यांना देशाभिमान आणि धर्माभिमान नसलेले राज्यकर्ते लाभले आहेत. कुणी एक आरपीएन सिंग नावाचा गृहराज्यमंत्री आहे. त्याने जाहीर केले आहे, ‘पाकिस्तानबरोबरचे क्रिकेट सामने होणारच. पाकिस्तानी क्रिकेटपटूंना आम्ही कडक सुरक्षा देऊ!’ मुंबईत राष्ट्रवादीचा कुणी नवाब मलिकही त्याचे सिलिंडर मोकळे करीत म्हणाला, ‘पाकिस्तानबरोबर क्रिकेट सामने व्हायलाच पाहिजेत!’ तिकडे भाजपच्या मुख्तार अब्बास नक्वीनेही मग ‘खेळात राजकारण आणू नये’ अशी टिचकी वाजवून स्वत:च्या भाजपचेच हसे करून घेतले. जम्मू-कश्मीरचा मुख्यमंत्री ओमर अब्दुल्लानेही पाकिस्तानबरोबरचे संबंध सुधारण्यासाठी क्रिकेट खेळावे असे सुचविले आहे. गृहमंत्री सुशीलकुमार शिंदे यांनीही या ‘पाकिस्तानी क्रिकेट डिप्लोमसी’त स्वत:चे चांदतारे तोडले आहेत. पाकिस्तानी क्रिकेटपटूंचे सामने हिंदुस्थानात होणारच असे सांगून त्यांची सेवा पाकचरणी रुजू केली आहे. ‘आपल्या देशात येणार्‍या इतर देशांतील खेळाडू आणि कलाकार यांची जबाबदारीही आपली असते. त्यांना संरक्षण देण्याचे कामही आपलेच आहे,’ अशी मुक्ताफळे त्यांनी उधळली आहेत. काय हो शिंदे, परकीय खेळाडू व कलाकारांना संरक्षण देण्याचे काम जर तुमचे आहे तर ज्या देशाचे गृहमंत्री म्हणून तुम्ही खुर्ची उबवीत आहात त्या हिंदुस्थानी नागरिकांना संरक्षण देण्याची जबाबदारी कुणाची आहे? या देशातील जनतेच्या जीविताचे आणि मालमत्तेचे पाक दहशतवाद्यांपासून रक्षण करण्याचे काम तुमचेच आहे ना? मग ते का होत नाही? पुन्हा ते अफजल गुरू, कसाब, तो अबू जिंदाल या सर्वांना तुम्ही जे खास संरक्षणात जिवंत ठेवले आहे ती देखील तुमची जबाबदारीच म्हणायची! नाही तरी गुरू, कसाब, जिंदाल हेदेखील ‘कलाकार’च
आहेत, दहशतवादी हल्ल्याची ‘कला’ त्यांनी या देशात रक्तामांसाचा चिखल करून दाखवून दिली आहे आणि हे सर्व पाकिस्तानातूनच आले आहेत. तेव्हा तुमच्या या कामगिरीसाठी तुम्हाला ‘निशान-ए-पाकिस्तान’ किंवा ‘ऑर्डर ऑफ पाकिस्तान’ किताब देऊन सन्मानच व्हायला हवा. एकंदरीत काय, पाकड्यांना विरोध करणारी देशाभिमानी जनता मूर्ख आणि पाकिस्तानची ‘चाटू’गिरी करणारी ही अवलाद तेवढी शहाणी. पाकिस्तानच्या स्वागतासाठी पायघड्या घालण्याचीच तयारी सुरू आहे. आम्ही एका प्रखर देशाभिमानी विचाराने पाकड्यांबरोबर क्रिकेट खेळण्यास विरोध केला आहे. यात आम्ही राजकीय फायद्या-तोट्याचे गणित कधीच पाहिले नाही. मुंबईवर ‘२६/११’ सारखा भयंकर हल्ला झालेला असताना आणि त्यात सांडलेले रक्त व निरपराध्यांच्या किंकाळ्या ताज्या असताना त्याच सैतानांशी क्रिकेट खेळताना तुम्हाला लाजा नाही वाटत? एकातरी क्रिकेटपटूचा देशाभिमान जागा होऊन त्याने तडफेने उठून जाहीर का करू नये की, ‘‘नाही खेळणार आम्ही त्या पाकड्यांबरोबर क्रिकेट. ज्यांनी आमच्या भारतमातेवर वारंवार निर्घृण हल्ले केले आहेत, मुंबई रक्ताने भिजवली, संसदेस तडे दिले त्यांच्याबरोबर क्रिकेट खेळणे चुकीचेच आहे.’’ मात्र क्रिकेट संघातील एकातरी हिंदुस्थानी खेळाडूच्या धमन्यांत सच्चे राष्ट्रभक्तीचे रक्त सळसळत असेल तर शपथ. सगळेच पैशाला पासरी व पैशासाठी हिरव्यांपुढेही हातपाय पसरी. सीमेवर जवानांनी शहीद व्हायचे. पाकड्यांच्या दहशतवादी हल्ल्यात निरपराध्यांनी मरायचे. तुकाराम ओंबळेसारख्यांनी प्राणाची बाजी लावून शहीद व्हायचे आणि त्याच भूमीत क्रिकेटपटू म्हणवून घेणार्‍या ‘व्यापार्‍यां’नी देशाभिमानाची ऐशी की तैशी करीत खेळाच्या नावाखाली पाकड्यांशी एकप्रकारे जुगाराचा डावच लावायचा. या मंडळींना हाती तिरंगा धरण्याचा अधिकार खरोखरच आहे काय? तो रक्तबंबाळ तिरंगाही
धाय मोकलून रडत असेल. सीमेवरील जवानांनीच आता या पाकड्यांशी क्रिकेट खेळणार्‍यांचा धिक्कार करून या मंडळींच्या खोट्या प्रतिष्ठेचा बँडबाजा वाजवायला हवा. ते गृहराज्यमंत्री सिंग काय किंवा गृहमंत्री सुशीलकुमार काय, यांना या पाकड्यांबद्दल एवढा पान्हा का फुटावा? काय तर म्हणे पाकड्यांना संरक्षण देऊ! कोण लागतात तुमचे ते पाकडे? एवढाच तुम्हाला त्यांचा पुळका आला असेल तर पाकिस्तानात चालते व्हा. असे संरक्षण देशाला मिळाले असते तर संसदेवरही हल्ला झाला नसता आणि मुंबईत कसाब घुसला नसता. ओमर अब्दुल्ला म्हणतो, पाकिस्तानशी क्रिकेट खेळूया, संबंध सुधारतील. मग काय रे कश्मीरच्या नासक्या सफरचंदा, तुझे तुझ्या कुटुंबाशी संबंध बिघडून प्रकरण ‘तलाक’पर्यंत का गेले? संबंध बिघडताच बंगल्याच्या हिरवळीवर किक्रेट खेळायचे व संबंध सुधारले असे जाहीर करायचे. क्रिकेटमध्ये इतकी जादू आहे ना? मग ममता बॅनर्जीबरोबर क्रिकेटचा सामना लावा आणि सरकारमधील बिघडलेले संबंध या क्रिकेटमुळे सुधारत असल्याचा दाखला द्या. जवानांच्या हाती बंदुका आहेत त्या पाकड्यांबरोबर लढण्यासाठी. त्या बंदुका म्हणजे बॅट आणि बॉम्ब म्हणजे बॉल नव्हेत. या देशातील राजकारणात नामर्द मच्छरांची पैदास वाढली आहे व त्या मच्छरांनी सारा देश नामर्द बनवला आहे. म्हणूनच पाकड्या अतिरेकी कसाबला एक मच्छर चावला आणि त्यास ‘डेंग्यू’ नावाचा आजार जडला. त्या मच्छराच्या मर्दपणाचे कौतुक करावे तेवढे थोडेच. यापुढे जे राज्यकर्ते क्रिकेटच्या निमित्ताने पाकड्यांची चाटूगिरी करतील त्यांच्या जिभेसही या मच्छराने डंख मारून राष्ट्रकार्य करावे. कसाबला चावून मर्दानगी दाखविणार्‍या या ‘डेंग्यू’ मच्छरास ‘भारतरत्न’ देण्याची शिफारस लोकांनीच आता केली आहे. काय हो पाकड्यांच्या ‘चाटू मंडळींनो, मच्छर मारू नका, पण निदान हिजड्यांप्रमाणे टाळ्या तरी वाजवा
BALKANIZING PAKISTAN: A COLLECTIVE NATIONAL SECURITY STRATEGY
Geopolitical journalist, Posted: July 6, 2010 05:43 AM
Breaking Pakistan to Fix It



The argument for Balkanizing Pakistan or, more specifically, fragmenting the Islamic Republic so it's easier to police and economically develop, has been on the table since Pakistan's birth in 1947 when the country was spit out of a British laboratory. And lately, the concept is looking more appealing by the day, because as a result of flawed boundaries combined with the nexus between military rule and Islamic extremism, Pakistan now finds itself on a rapid descent toward certain collapse and the country's leaders stubbornly refuse to do the things required to change course. But before allowing Pakistan to commit state suicide, self-disintegrate and further destabilize the region, the international community can beat them to the punch and deconstruct the country less violently.



To quell any doubts about Pakistan's seemingly uncontrollable spiral into darkness, just recently, Foreign Policy Magazine ranked Pakistan as the tenth most failed state on earth and it would seem its leaders are hell bent on securing the number one slot - an honor it can add to their already dubious distinction as the world's largest incubator of jihadist extremism. Afghanistan will never see peace or prosperity with a neighbor like Pakistan and the U.S. will always be threatened by terrorist plots spawned in Pakistan's lawless regions - like the most recent Times Square bombing.



The most popular approach to fragmentation is to break off and allow Afghanistan to absorb Pakistan's North-West Frontier Province (NWFP) and the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA), which would unite the Pashtun tribes. In addition, the provinces of Balochistan and Sindh would become independent sovereign states, leaving Punjab as a standalone entity.



Balkanization is based on the premise that the weak central government in Islamabad is incapable of governing Pakistan's frontiers, which have become the number one source of regional instability. The governing Punjabi elite have neglected the other three major ethnic groups - the Sindhis, Pashtuns, and Baluchis, primarily because a majority of Pakistan's budget is spent on the military rather than economic development, schooling or infrastructure. Only 2% of Pakistan's GDP, for example, is spent on education despite the fact Pakistan's literacy rate stands at 57%.



Minority groups have also been underrepresented in institutions such as Pakistan's military - which is the country's most powerful entity. Punjabis who represent 40% of the population constitute 90% of the armed forces. Pakistan's own history provides a prime case study of what happens when an ethnic group can no longer tolerate political and economic disregard. After a quarter century of strife the Bengalis rebelled, seceded and founded Bangladesh in 1971.



If the Balkanization solution is ever put in motion, accusations will surely fly that it's yet another example of U.S. imperialism and neo-conservatism run amok. However, this would be a diplomatic and multilateral effort, plus, it is more about reversing the iniquities of British colonialism than it is building some new world order.



Inherent Instability



Pakistan's problems began when the British drew its boundaries haphazardly, which was primarily a product of incompetence and haste than maniacal design. According to an article in the New York Times last year, British colonial officer, Sir Cyril Radcliffe was given six weeks to carve a Muslim-majority state from British India although he had never even been there before. Radcliffe's private secretary was quoted as saying that Sir Cyril "was a bit flummoxed by the whole thing. It was a rather impossible assignment, really. To partition that subcontinent in six weeks was absurd." It would be a comical anecdote except for the fact that hundreds of thousands of people died in the ethnic cleansing that followed as a direct result of British carelessness.



Pakistan's border with Afghanistan - the poorly-marked Durand Line - had been drawn in 1893, also by the British, but it was never meant to be a long-term legally-binding boundary. The faux demarcation split the Pashtuns in half. By reinstating the original natural boundaries, Pakistan's western provinces would be returned to Afghanistan and the Pashtun tribes would be reunited. Such a move would also remove a strategic advantage for the Afghan Taliban, who can easily blend in amongst fellow Pashtuns on the Pakistani side of the border today.



The British did not only gift Pakistan with lethal boundaries, according to renowned Pakistani journalist Ahmed Rashid, Pakistan inherited a "security state" from British rule, described by scholars as "the viceregal tradition" or "a permanent state of martial law". Intellectual Christopher Hitchens asserted Pakistan has been a fiefdom of the military for most of its short existence. As was once said of Prussia: Pakistan is not a country that has an army, but an army that has a country. Hitchens also said the country was doomed to be a dysfunctional military theocracy from day one - beginning with the very name of the country itself:



But then, there is a certain hypocrisy inscribed in the very origins and nature of "Pakistan". The name is no more than an acronym, confected in the 1930s at Cambridge University by a NW Muslim propagandist named Chaudhri Rahmat Ali. It stands for Punjab, Afghania, Kashmir, and Indus-Sind, plus the suffix "-stan," meaning "land." In the Urdu tongue, the resulting word means "Land of the Pure." The country is a cobbling together of regional, religious, and ethnic nationalisms, and its founding, in 1947, resulted in Pakistan's becoming, along with Israel, one of the two "faith-based" states to emerge from the partitionist policy of a dying British colonialism. Far from being a "Land of the Pure," Pakistan is one of the clearest demonstrations of the futility of defining a nation by religion, and one of the textbook failures of a state and a society.

Pakistan deteriorated throughout the decades because of its focus on building the military and developing Islamic extremist groups to use as weapons in their eternal obsessive struggle against India. It's true the U.S. helped Pakistan build these groups since the beginning of the Cold War, but America learned on 9/11 they had created a Frankenstein monster that now needed to be slain.



Many analysts have suggested India is less of a national security threat to Pakistan than its homegrown terrorist groups, many of which have openly declared their mission to topple the state, which would allow jihadists to secure nuclear materials. Yet, based on its strategic decision to foster extremism and its recent public support for Taliban rule in Afghanistan, it appears the biggest existential threat to Pakistan is its own political and military leaders.



The Last Straw



With that being said, Balkanization does seem like an extreme step at first blush, and perhaps Pakistan should be given another chance. Yet, after considering Pakistan's historic and current relationship with Al Qaeda - it becomes much easier to justify.



Since the war began in 2001 the U.S. has asked Pakistan to root out extremists from sanctuaries in a Rhode Island-sized area called North Waziristan, chief among them being the lethal Haqqani Network. However, Pakistan's army chief General Ashfaq Kayani asserted his forces were too bogged down fighting the Pakistani Taliban elsewhere in places like South Waziristan, Orakzai Agency and various districts across the NWFP.



I contacted an Afghan intelligence analyst about this and he assessed General Kayani's claim with one single word: rubbish. The Pakistan army consists of 500,000 active duty troops and another 500,000 on reserve. If Pakistan truly wanted to capture the Haqqani Network they would be able to drag them out of their caves by their beards within a few days.



In a movement that should have floored U.S. policymakers, Kayani was brazen enough to try and inveigle Afghanistan to strike a power-sharing arrangement with the Haqqanis. And Kayani, apparently the spokesperson for the Haqqani group, said they'd be willing to split from and denounce Al Qaeda, which is President Obama's primary rationale for the war. However, there is a higher probability of General Kayani converting to Hinduism than there is of the Haqqani Network ever being decoupled from Al Qaeda.



According to the Long War Journal, Siraj Haqqani, their leader, sits on Al Qaeda's decision-making body. Haqqani's friendship with Osama bin Laden dates back to the war against the Soviets in the 1980s and it was Haqqani that ensured safe passage into Pakistan for many Al Qaeda figures after the collapse of the Taliban in 2001. An Institute for the Study of War analysis concluded that Haqqani was "irreconcilable" and negotiations with him would actually strengthen Al Qaeda and would undermine the raison d'etre for U.S. involvement in Afghanistan over the past decade.



In other words, the Haqqani Network is Al Qaeda.



Pakistan has had a close relationship with the Haqqanis for over 30 years, who are still seen as a crucial anti-Indian asset. So, for nine years the Pakistanis protected the Haqqanis and claimed ignorance as to the whereabouts of Mullah Omar, Osama bin Laden and the Quetta Shura. Nine years, nearly $300 billion dollars and 1900 dead coalition soldiers later, the U.S. has officially verified that the entire war effort has been focused on the wrong side of the mountains.



A stable Afghanistan is in Pakistan's best interests, but this message has been preached time and again with little to no results, and the U.S. has waited long enough for Pakistan's leaders to uproot the extremists that orchestrated 9/11. But now, it appears as if the international community will have to do it for them.

Tuesday, 6 November 2012

62 war have we learnt correct lessons

Given the mess India’s higher defence management is, the government must take steps to build an abiding civil-military relationship.
The Context
Much water has flown down the tributaries of mighty Brahmaputra since the fatal night of 19/20 October 1962 when the Sino-Indian war commenced. Yet, it has not washed away the shame of India’s humiliating defeat, caused by “unspeakably incompetent generals and the political leaders that had assigned them the commands for which they were unfit”, if the spate of recently published articles are to be believed. 
After five decades, one could see similarities in the present scenario. Civil-Military relationship was dismal then and remains so because politicians and bureaucrats continue to adhere to the age-old notion of Alfred Lord Tennyson: “Theirs is not to reason why, but to do and die.” (Charge of the Light Brigade-1854.) Union Minister of State of Defence while delivering the Field Marshal KM Cariappa Memorial Lecture in October 2012 virtually defined the relationship on above lines: ‘The military forces have remained loyal to the elected government and have been its obedient servant.’
Ironically, from the military side this relationship has been articulated by two Service Chiefs who were prematurely maneuvered out of office due to their refusal to be mere ‘obedient servants’. Admiral Vishnu Bhagwat in his treatise The Soldier and the State (1998) has said: “The modern military profession exists as part of the government insofar as the term 'government' includes the executive departments of the nation-state...Modern democracies therefore pay great attention to the supremacy of the political class over the military in governance, normally referred to as 'civilian control of the military’. This is clearly how it should be, since ultimate power and decision making should be wielded by the elected representatives of the people.” 
General VK Singh fully endorsed this (2012) but challenged the Tennyson dogma: “Civilian supremacy must always be rooted on the fundamental principles of justice, merit and fairness. Violation of this in any form must be resisted if we are to protect the Institutional Integrity of our Armed Forces.”  
Combined views of former Navy and Army Chiefs go beyond ‘loyalty’ and ‘obedience’ and set forth certain non-negotiable imperatives for civil-military relationship:
·         Democracy functioning as per established norms;
·         Military profession existing as part of government;
·         Decision making and civilian supremacy by the ‘elected representatives of the people’;
·         Such supremacy to be rooted on the principles of justice, merit and fairness;
·         Violation of this can be resisted to protect the Institutional Integrity of Armed Forces.
Democratic Republic of India is constituted in order to secure to all its citizens “Justice, social, economic and political; Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and opportunity” and to promote among them all “Fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the nation.” India’s professional Armed Force is meant to defend, protect and safeguard this Democratic Republic wherein live one-sixth of the human race.

Bureaucracy or Adhocracy?
Despite shortcomings, Indian military is professional in its structure and functioning. It has primary and secondary roles. Former is to preserve national interests and safeguard sovereignty, territorial integrity and unity of India against any external threats and the latter is assisting Government agencies to cope with ‘proxy war’ and other internal threats and provide aid to civil authority when requisitioned for the purpose. The present generation has seen Armed Forces, particularly the Army, more in the secondary role than the primary one. It is in this context that we should critically look at national security, the role of military as well as civil-military relationship so that these could be mainstreamed into the governance architecture. 
What are the factors that prevent such mainstreaming? First is the strong administrative, procedural and bureaucratic control over the armed forces without any expertise in military affairs. Second, exclusion of military from crucial decision-making forums, thus denying it a role in the policy-making process, strategic assessments and weapons procurement, all having adverse effect on defence preparedness and national security. 
Even so, military has considerable autonomy concerning its own affairs: training and education, threat assessments, force structure, doctrine, innovations, appointments (up to a certain rank) and miscellaneous welfare activities. This practice of strong bureaucratic control with military autonomy is paradoxical and could create more conflicts than it could resolve! 
Is the control really bureaucratic? One wonders! Bureaucracy administers through laid down rules and is by and large merit-driven. Adhocracy on the other hand is nurtured through violation of processes and procedures to ensure that favoritism and nepotism prevails. Such adhocracy, which is antonymous to meritocracy, has substantially subverted the decision-making process and governance standards vastly encouraging corruption and dishonesty.
It started with the civil services, spread to the military and blossomed into a joint-venture between civil and military adhocracies. Malfunctioning of this adhocracy has in recent years severely soured the Civil-military relationship.
Governance as the catalyst
Civil and military are both sides of governance. Though military should be an intrinsic part of India’s governance it is not so because there is an inherent conflict between the two streams-one of mediocrity versus excellence. As always mediocrity keeps excellence at arm’s length and given the current civil-military equation the twain shall never meet! Instead, driven by self-interest, military, at least the higher echelons seem to be drifting towards mediocrity. This indeed is the dilemma.
The way out is to redefine governance and make ‘Human Security’ as a new paradigm for development and governance. ‘Human security’ combines and harnesses four vital elements-material sufficiency, human dignity, democracy and participatory governance-that constitute the core of a civilised human society. Governance, structured around such concept of ‘security’ can strive towards and achieve excellence. 
Once we broad base "defense" or "military" and move towards "security" sector, civil society participation becomes imperative in human/national security strategies, military affairs and expenditures. Governance then could really become a catalyst for civil-military relationships and adhocracies will have no place in such relationship. For this to happen a specific role needs to be assigned to the civil society so that the issue is dealt with in a democratic rather than adhocratic manner. 
Suggesting Solutions
Theories on civil-military relationship abound. It is time we got practical and look at what is doable and what should be done.  
In a ‘functioning’ democracy, Parliamentary oversight is the best form of ‘civilian control of the military' instead of the whims of individual ministers and bunch of bureaucrats. Such oversight could play a major role in defining a set of rules governing the relationship between civilian authorities and the military, and balancing the financial needs of defense and security with the needs of other sectors. 
Given the mess that India’s higher defence management is, it appears best to emulate the model that centralises military’s operational authority through the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs as opposed to the service chiefs. With this concept at the core, following steps could be taken to build and sustain an abiding civil-military relationship:
·         Re-visiting the entire rubric of higher defence management and role of bureaucracy, factoring the reports of various committees;
·         Legislation to institutionalise the ‘fully joint force’ and Parliamentary oversight/involvement in defence management;
·         Amending Government of India Rules of Business 1961 to recognize the role of military in national security making them integral to the governance structure;
·         Scrutiny of the delegated authority of the President under Rules of Business and its rectification to prevent misuse for pursuing political and private agenda;
·         Abolishing adhocracy in MoD by replacing the archaic ‘generalist’ practice in senior appointments with domain knowledge/experience;
·         Reconfiguring national security framework with inputs from all stake-holders and involvement of civil society;
·         Bridging the distance between communities, academia, think tanks and the military through transparency and assistance from civil society.
End-Note 
General turned President Dwight Eisenhower made a statement that reiterated what Kautilya had said two thousand years ago: “When diplomats fail to maintain peace, the soldier is called upon to restore peace. When civil administration fails to maintain order, the soldier is called to restore order. As the nation’s final safeguard, the army cannot afford a failure in either circumstance. Failure of army can lead to national catastrophe, endangering the survival of the nation”. Nothing more need to be said on the criticality of an abiding and cordial civil-military relationship.
Such relationship cannot float on shallow waters, but should be moored on an unshakable anchor. In war or conflicts military men do not offer the 'supreme sacrifice' just for money or rank. There is something far more precious called 'Honour' and this is embedded in the Chetwood Hall credo which most military leaders have passed through.
Civil-military relationship moored on such anchor would subsist on equality and equity, not supremacy and subservience.